Return of the Pack Stay Informed
Main Content Region

LEAD Butterfly Project

PERSISTING INEQUALITIES AND PATHS FORWARD:
A Report on the State of Undocumented Students in California’s Public Universities

This report is the result of a collective research effort between the UC Collaborative to Promote Immigrant and Student Equity (UC PromISE) and the Undocumented Student Equity Project (USEP). Both generate research with the goal of informing policies and practices that will advance equity and inclusion for undocumented students.

This research was made possible by funding from the University of California Multicampus Research Programs and Initiatives. Additional funding was provided by the CSU Channel Islands Vice President for Student Affairs Office, CSU Fresno Kremen School of Education & Human Development 2019/2020 Research, Scholarship, and Creative Activities Award, CSU Los Angeles College of Education, CSU Sacramento Center on Race, Immigration, and Social Justice and San Francisco State University College of Science and Engineering.

Authors

  • Dr. Laura E. Enriquez, UC Irvine
  • Dr. Cecilia Ayón, UC Riverside
  • Dr. Karina Chavarria, CSU Channel Islands
  • Dr. Basia Ellis, Sacramento State University
  • Dr. Melissa J. Hagan, San Francisco State University
  • Dr. Julián Jefferies, CSU Fullerton
  • Jannet Lara, M.A., Independent Scholar
  • Martha Morales Hernandez, M.A., UC Irvine
  • Dr. Enrique Murillo Jr., CSU San Bernardino
  • Dr. Jennifer Nájera, UC Riverside
  • Dr. Carly Offidani-Bertrand, CSU San Marcos
  • Dr. Maria Oropeza Fujimoto, CSU Los Angeles
  • Dr. Annie Ro, UC Irvine
  • Victoria E. Rodriguez, MSW, MPH, UC Irvine
  • Dr. William Rosales, CSU Los Angeles
  • Dr. Heidy Sarabia, Sacramento State University
  • Dr. Ana K. Soltero López, CSU Fresno
  • Dr. Mercedes Valadez, Sacramento State University
  • Dr. Sharon Velarde Pierce, CSU San Bernardino
  • Dr. Zulema Valdez, UC Merced

 

Forthcoming- Special Issue of the Journal of Latinos and Education - Topic: Undocumented Students

Contents:
- Directions for Future Research on Undocumented Students: Lessons from a Survey of California College Students
- The Driving Role of Campus Climate on the Academic Engagement of Undocumented College Students
- Physically Present, Yet Cognitively Absent: A Latent Profile Analysis of Immigration-Related Distractions and Academic Engagement among Undocumented College Students
- Evaluating the Effect of Legal Vulnerabilities and Social Support on the Mental Health of Undocumented College Students
- Politically Excluded, Undocu-Engaged: The Perceived Effect of Hostile Immigration Policies on Undocumented Student Civic and Political Engagement
- Life After College: Liminal Legal Status and Shifting Policies as a Barrier to Undocumented Students’ Career Preparation Pursuits
- “I Think It’s Funny That Because I’m Undocumented, I Got a Free Ride”: Divergent Perceptions of Legal Status Among Undocumented College Students
- What Helps Students Get Help?: An Exploratory Analysis of Individual and Campus Factors that Shape Undocumented College Students’ Use of Academic Resources


LEAD Projects - blueprint to Support Undocumented Students (2000):

1. Increase College Access
• Develop a coordinated outreach plan with immigrant youth-led organizations, immigrant advocacy coalitions, and other community-based organizations to build trust and help undocumented students learn about accessing the community college system
• Strengthen the K-12 pipeline to engage undocumented students, parents, teachers, and counselors and facilitate transition to higher education
• Recruit undocumented students as community ambassadors and student role models
• Develop online sites that promote programs and resources for undocumented students
• Promote dual enrollment in high school and college courses as a cost-saving college preparation strategy

2. Make College Affordable Through Financial Assistance
• Assist in finding and applying for available scholarship resources
• Increase college and private fundraising for scholarship opportunities
• Adopt institutional funding for scholarship-based internships

3. Support College Readiness and Success
• Designate staff responsible for advising undocumented students
• Provide professional development to college personnel about unique challenges facing undocumented students and resources to help them
• Engage parents and keep them involved during the college experience

4. Offer Alternatives for Adult Learners
• Connect adult education and community college systems through partnerships and case management
• Adopt ABE-ESL bridge courses, career pathways, and online learning to support adult students

5. Improve College Retention and Completion
• Promote campus safe zones and empower immigrant students as leaders
• Provide a continuum of support services to promote the academic, social, and emotional well-being of undocumented students
• Organize campus-wide events to build institutional awareness and support for undocumented students
• Facilitate transfer to the workplace


Commentary (2021):

CSUSB has always been very supportive of student success and has demonstrated a strong commitment to undocumented members of our campus community. There are numerous examples and demonstrative evidence.

Nearly 20 years ago, in the 2000s our campus established Students for Equal Access to Education at California State University, San Bernardino; which was the first undocumented student support group on campus. Then of course our students, faculty and staff participated in the now famous “Rally for the Undocumented” to raise awareness on the injustice undocumented people of all ages face in this country.

We were among the first to hold the very first Youth Empowerment trainings for undocumented youth. We also worked with MALDEF in late 2002 to produce AB 540 Materials.

Since January 1, 2002, California’s AB 540 law had allowed undocumented immigrant students in pursuit of a higher education who meet specific requirements to be exempt from paying out-of-state tuition fees.

Since 2007 we have co-sponsored Annual Immigrant Youth Empowerment Conferences throughout CA.

In 2010 our campus produced the first nationwide virtual programming on CA’s AB 540, to serve as model for the nation. In 2010 also produced national virtual programming on the DREAM Act. In 2010 we also co-hosted an event in partnership with the Inland Empire DREAM Team, "Undocumented Town Hall". We also co-sponsored Dreams and Education: AB 540 & DREAM Act Conference.

In 2012 we disseminated the first Listas de Las Becas para el CA Dream Act. As you know the California Dream Act of 2011, authored by Assembly Member Gil Cedillo (Los Angeles), became law through the passage of two Assembly Bills, AB 130 and AB 131. AB 130 allows students who meet AB 540 criteria (California Education Code 68130.5(a)) to apply for and receive non-state funded scholarships for public colleges and universities. AB 131 allows students who meet AB 540 criteria to apply for and receive state-funded financial aid such as institutional grants, community college fee waivers, Cal Grant and Chafee Grant.

And in the same year, we co-sponsored the first-ever West Coast DREAM Graduation, held June 30th, 2012.

In 2014 our campus joined the NATIONAL SCHOLARSHIP PROGRAM FOR UNDOCUMENTED IMMIGRANT STUDENTS, the first of its kind.

Our campus president also, among his early initiatives, organized the Immigration Reform Event (April 2013). Also first to offer campus presentations on UNDOCUMENTED WOMEN with the WOMEN'S RESOURCE CENTER, LEAD, AND THE MEXICAN CONSULATE. We also featured the full story of Dr. Alfredo Quiñones-Hinojosa, M.D., an undocumented immigrant from Mexicali, Mexico who was working the vegetable fields of the Central Valley in California when he "jumped the fence" in 1987 at age 19. Dr. Alfredo Quiñones-Hinojosa, M.D. went on, after a long educational journey, to the John Hopkins School of Medicine as a neurosurgeon who teaches oncology and neurosurgery, directs a neurosurgery clinic and heads a laboratory studying brain tumors.

Since 2011 we established LEAD programming, including Feria Educativa, to inform undocumented community and prospective k-12 about higher education opportunities. We were also there in 2012 when 9 undocumented youth held a coming out of the shadows event at San Bernardino City Hall.  After they revealed their status the youth marched to the Department of Homeland Security building and engaged in non-violent civil disobedience.

11 years ago we created the first resource guide for undocumented students. For nearly 20 years we also worked with the Association of Raza Educators to provide undocumented students with an opportunity to realize their dreams of attending college with a scholarship.

This topic touches my heart, really hits home.  As the son of Mexican immigrants from Culican Sinaloa, my parents were heavily involved in social justice issues for the betterment of our communities. Until the 1990's, undocumented immigrant students were allowed to attend California's colleges and universities as state residents if they could demonstrate that they had lived in the state for a year and a day prior to application and intended to make California their home. In 1985 immigrant students won a court order that held that the Education Code precluding undocumented students from establishing residence is unconstitutional and that these students could establish state residence for tuition purposes for both the University of California (UC) and California State University (CSU) systems.

So in the mid-80’s as an EOP Counselor at Cal State Long Beach I was part of the Leticia A. Network, a coalition named after the student in the successful state district court case. Composed of counselors, teachers and employees from all three higher education segments, community advocates, students, parents, and civil rights advocates, the Network exchanged information on the policies and practices at different campuses across the state concerning the classification of undocumented students.

Then in the late 1980’s I served as REGIONAL DIRECTOR / CHIEF OF OPERATIONS of One Stop Immigration and Educational Center with many schools/offices across Southern California; and later CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER of Ollin, Inc., where we back then in our case alone we helped legalize more than 10,000 families during the Immigration Reform and Control Act of 1986, known as IRCA Amnesty.

But by late 1991/early1992 the political pendulum and gains had swung back.  

A UC employee in the registrar’s office named Bradford sued University of CA in an employment action, claiming that he had been forced to quit because he would not follow the Leticia A. order…and he won the injunction against the UC.  The California Student Aid Commission adopted the Bradford ruling in spring 1992, and stopped awarding Cal Grants to undocumented students. And although the California Community Colleges (CCC) was not named in the Bradford case, it issued guidelines interpreting Bradford in February 1992.

All three segments of public higher education in California were effectively closed off to newly enrolling undocumented immigrant students. With the passage of Proposition 187 in 1994, all seemed lost. Proposition 187 prohibited undocumented students from attending all public schools, from kindergarten through college and university level. Civil rights organizations immediately challenged the constitutionality of Proposition 187. I myself served on call as a teacher witness involved in the litigious effort to overturn 187; which indeed was ruled unconstitutional.

But while undocumented immigrant students were still allowed to attend California's colleges and universities, the Bradford case remained the legal rule -- regardless of how long they lived in California, they were required to pay non-resident tuition, over three times the rate that their high school classmates paid. This usually meant they could not afford the opportunity of a higher education, a loss to them and the state, especially considering they were academically eligible.

By 2011, then Governor Davis signed AB 540 (Firebaugh/Maldonado). The bill exempts undocumented immigrant students from paying out-of-state tuition if they have attended California’s high schools for three years and graduated from a California high school. While this relief does not classify undocumented students as residents, the out-of-state tuition exemption has the practical effect of making a higher education more accessible financially.

But one of the pressing issues despite the enactment of policies at all three systems of higher education implementing AB 540, is that many students and counselors still do not know about this exemption.

From 2008 through 2012 I served as the State Financial Aid Commissioner for the CA Student Aid Commission, and later the President of Edfund.  It was during this period that the 2011 CA DREAM Act passed (AB 130 and AB 131) and our Commission was charged with the implementation.

In the first year, almost 32,000 undocumented students completed a California DREAM Act application. Of those, about 7,500 received some form of Cal Grant.

A few years back in the Governor’s Budget there is Cal Grant Program Growth - an increase of $68.9 million to the General Fund in 2014 15; and $198.2 million to the General Fund in 2015 16, to reflect increased participation in the Cal Grant program. * and of these adjustments, $48.3 million in 2014 15 and $67 million in 2015 16 are attributable to the continuing implementation of the California Dream Act.

In our Inland Empire region we (the LEAD Organization) also had began coordinating FREE LEAD Cash for College workshops. Jointly planned with our Partners of the IE Regional Collaborative, we had hosted more than 100 FREE Cash for College workshops across San Bernardino and Riverside Counties every year.  And in just a few years time, we had assisted more than 15,000 families in the Inland Empire to complete their FAFSA financial aid application. Our initiative has brought in more than $78 million dollars to our region in what may or would have been otherwise unclaimed financial aid monies!


Useful Reports and Tools:


- In Their Voices: Undocumented in California Public Colleges and Universities (The Campaign for College Opportunity)
https://collegecampaign.org/portfolio/in-their-voices/

- Use the interactive map below to find information about campus centers for undocumented students, support programs, website addresses with relevant information, and contact information of undocumented allies/liaisons. This information is critical to improve access and success for undocumented students in higher education (The Campaign for College Opportunity)
https://collegecampaign.org/undoc-student-resources/

- UNDOCUCOLLEGE GUIDE & EQUITY TOOL - CALIFORNIA 2016
WORKING TOWARD EDUCATIONAL EQUITY & INCLUSION OF UNDOCUMENTED
STUDENTS AT INSTITUTIONS OF HIGHER EDUCATION IN CALIFORNIA
https://immigrantsrising.org/wp-content/uploads/Immigrants-Rising_CA-UndocuCollege-Guide-and-Equity-Tool_Full-Report.pdf


Dreamers Resource Center opens at San Bernardino Valley College


Dr. Enrique Murillo, executive director of LEAD and professor at CSUSB, named grand marshal of the event:
https://www.fontanaheraldnews.com/news/dreamers-resource-center-opens-at-san-bernardino-valley-college/article_6040a2aa-e456-11e4-ba8f-cf31c50753aa.html